Buy, Sell, Trade, Donate

Card Games, Video Games, Boards Games & Books

Last updated: June 2026

At Legacy Games, we are always looking to purchase used games. Trade in your used and unused games for store credit or cash.

We maintain the right to decline any product purchases at our discretion.

We Buy

Trading Card Singles
Video Games
Clean, Working Consoles
OEM Controllers & Accessories

We Do NOT Buy

Damaged trading cards
Newly release trading cards within 2-weeks of release date
Shovelware (Sports, Fitness, Toys-to-Life, Motion Controlled games)
Loose, scratched or damaged games
Broken, yellowed, incomplete or untested consoles
Games under $5 market price or excessive duplicates

TCG Trade-In Value

Rares over $3:

55% cash / 70% store-credit

Bulk Magic: the Gathering cards:

$5 per 1,000 commons/uncommons

$0.10 per bulk rare/mythic

$0.20 per bulk foil rare/mythic

If you're looking to sell a larger collection, please email us sales@legacygamestore.com or give us a call! (585) 866-GAME

Video Game Trade-In Value

Video Games & Accessories:

45% cash / 60% store-credit

Video Game Consoles:

60% cash / 75% store-credit

Bulk Video Games (<$10):

$1 cash / $2 credit (must be clean, complete, non-duplicate)

WE BUY GAMES

Buy, Sell, Trade, Donate

TCG Trade-In Value

Video Game Trade-In Value